state of play: 09/02/2024
STATE OF PLAY: Łętowska: The Constitutional Tribunal Practically Doesn't Exist. It Has Lost Authority. Similarly, Two Chambers of the Supreme Court, Groblewski: What Do We Get From Politicians in Return? Hate-Filled Clips, Domański: Mild Decriminalization
-- "PLEASE WAIT FOR FRIDAY" - BODNAR ON FURTHER LAWS - 300LIVE: https://300polityka.pl/live/2024/09/02
-- NEW TELEVISION WPOLSCE 24 HAS LAUNCHED, INTERVIEW WITH JAROSŁAW KACZYŃSKI AT 7:30 PM:
https://wpolityce.pl/media/704462-ruszyla-nowa-telewizja-wpolsce-24-zapraszamy
-- EMAILS MICHAŁ DWORCZYK DIDN'T WANT TO SHOW INVESTIGATORS - WOJCIECH CZUCHNOWSKI IN GW: "Earlier – in August 2018 – Dworczyk informed the Prime Minister about the dissatisfaction of President Duda's camp that 'the Chancellery of the Prime Minister is unlawfully interfering in matters related to defense.' The email contains an interesting thread about the government blocking officer nominations granted by the president, which caused 'complaints': 'the blockade of promotions to the first officer rank, I told you recently that they sent applications for individuals against whom criminal cases are pending, including those related to sexual harassment, which we blocked.'"
https://wyborcza.pl/7,75398,31269759,wyborcza-ujawnia-jakie-mejle-probowal-wykasowac-michal-dworczyk.html
-- MINISTER DOMAŃSKI'S PRAYER FOR GROWTH (AND FOR INFLATION) - WITOLD GADOMSKI IN GW: "Minister Domański, speaking to Campus participants, did not explain on what basis his optimistic forecasts were made. His statements resembled Mateusz Morawiecki's monologues. (...) The government is borrowing more and more in foreign currencies, which is cheaper in the short term but very risky. Apparently, the Ministry of Finance assumes that no serious political or financial crisis will occur abroad in the coming years, which would result in a depreciation of the zloty."
-- WHAT HAS CHANGED IN FOUR MONTHS THAT THE MINISTRY IS SO SIGNIFICANTLY CORRECTING ITS FORECASTS? WHAT IS THE CREDIBILITY OF THE CURRENT FORECAST? - GADOMSKI CONTINUES IN GW: "What has changed in four months that the ministry is so significantly correcting its forecasts? What is the credibility of the current forecast? Credibility is fundamental here. The government of the democratic coalition seems incapable of any savings or even rationalization of expenses, and the finance minister assures that no savings are needed, that somehow it will work out."
https://wyborcza.pl/7,75968,31269702,modlitwa-ministra-domanskiego-o-wzrost-i-o-inflacje.htmlto-blekitna-maszyna-ktora-podtrzymuje-zycie-na-ziemi.html
-- WHAT DO WE GET FROM POLITICIANS IN RETURN? PARTY CLIPS FULL OF HATE, DEEPENING DIVISIONS TO ACHIEVE A BETTER RESULT - KAZIMIERZ GROBLEWSKI IN RZ: "Does this significant financial effort that the budget makes for parties return to society? What do we get from politicians in return? Party clips full of hate, deepening divisions to achieve a better result, higher poll ratings; attacking foreigners, spreading xenophobic sentiments, dividing us into better and worse based on religious beliefs, or who we sleep with."
-- IT IS WITH OUR MONEY THAT POLITICIANS DIVIDE US. THEY ARE UNABLE TO AGREE ACROSS PARTY LINES EVEN ON THE MOST IMPORTANT MATTERS - GROBLEWSKI CONTINUES IN RZ: "It is with our money that politicians divide us. They are unable to agree across party lines even on the most important matters for Poland, meaning for Poles: international alliances, membership in the European Union, adopting the euro, migration policy, energy policy, educational priorities, major investments."
https://www.rp.pl/opinie-polityczno-spoleczne/art41050451-kazimierz-groblewski-po-decyzji-pkw-dajemy-politykom-duzo-dostajemy-malo
-- THE COMPOSITION OF THE PKW IS UNFAIR TO PIS, BUT KACZYŃSKI HIMSELF IS TO BLAME. HE FELL INTO HIS OWN TRAP - PIOTR PACEWICZ IN OKO.PRESS: "According to the Electoral Code, PiS should have three nominees in the PKW, and the ruling coalition four. However, the code, which was meant to entrench the right-wing's rule forever, has been used to settle electoral transgressions. Kaczyński fell into the trap he set for the opposition."
-- IF KACZYŃSKI HAD NOT CHANGED THE ELECTORAL CODE, SIX OUT OF NINE PKW MEMBERS WOULD HAVE BEEN WOMEN: MAŁGORZATA MANOWSKA AND THE PRESIDENT'S 'SOCIAL ACQUAINTANCE,' JULIA PRZYŁĘBSKA FROM THE SO-CALLED CT - PACEWICZ CONTINUES IN OKO: "Kaczyński must be kicking himself now for being in such a hurry. If he hadn't changed the electoral code, six out of the nine PKW members would have been women: Małgorzata Manowska, First President of the Supreme Court, loyal to the previous government, and the president's 'social acquaintance,' Julia Przyłębska from the so-called Constitutional Tribunal. Perhaps Krystyna Pawłowicz and Stanisław Piotrowicz would have participated in the evaluation of electoral reports. Their terms in the so-called CT last until 2028, so PiS could have also utilized their talents in the PKW."
-- TRANSITIONAL JUSTICE INVOLVES USING HALF-MEASURES AND METHODS THAT ARE NOT ENTIRELY CLEAN. THE POINT IS NOT TO LOSE SIGHT OF THE FUNDAMENTAL DIRECTION OF DEMOCRATIZATION IN ALL OF THIS - PACEWICZ CONTINUES IN OKO: "Transitional justice involves using half-measures and methods that are not entirely clean. The point is not to lose sight of the fundamental direction of democratizing the state in all of this. In the case of the electoral code, this would mean taking away this 'toy' from politicians and ultimately restoring the control of the judiciary, as well as legally specifying what is permissible and what is not permissible for whom during an election campaign. It is also necessary to create conditions for professional campaign monitoring instead of the improvisation we have just witnessed."
https://oko.press/sklad-pkw-jest-krzywdzacy-dla-pis-ale-kaczynski-sam-sobie-winien-wpadl-w-sidla-ktore-zastawil
-- I ACCEPT THE LEGAL VOLUNTARISM OF THOSE CURRENTLY IN POWER, BUT ONLY ON THE CONDITION OF SWIFT ACTIONS THAT WILL RESTORE OR IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF POLISH DEMOCRACY. If it uses the instruments of politics distorted by PiS for its own purposes, it will not only fail but also push Polish democracy into fatally risky waters - BOGUSŁAW CHRABOTA IN RZ:
https://www.rp.pl/opinie-polityczno-spoleczne/art41055711-boguslaw-chrabota-pkw-walczy-z-pokusa-autorytaryzmu
-- THIS IS A KIND OF MILD DECRIMINALIZATION BY HITTING PIS FINANCIALLY - PROF. HENRYK DOMAŃSKI ON WPOLITYCE.PL: "It is known that Civic Platform and Donald Tusk aim to decriminalize PiS, but they realized after a few months that decriminalization would not succeed because a new PiS would simply emerge. Therefore, this is a kind of mild decriminalization by hitting the party financially."
https://wpolityce.pl/polityka/704403-prof-domanski-o-decyzji-pkw-lagodna-delegalizacja-pis
-- PIS IS FALLING INTO ITS OWN TRAP - TOMASZ SAWCZUK IN KULTURA LIBERALNA: "One could say that in both cases, PiS is falling into its own trap. Regarding the Supreme Court, the current chaos stems from changes introduced by PiS and a lack of willingness to rectify the situation. As for the PKW, Jarosław Kaczyński claims its composition is political, and the ruling is a political revenge by Donald Tusk, which targets the largest opposition party. However, the selection of commission members by parliament was introduced by PiS in 2018, and the general resolution describes actual irregularities, not imagined accusations."
-- THE MEDAL SHOULD GO TO THE PERSON WHO COMES UP WITH A WAY TO GET OFF THIS CAROUSEL, WHICH IS NOT A CAROUSEL OF LAUGHTER - SAWCZUK CONTINUES IN KULTURA LIBERALNA: "We are left with one more unknown: how will the potential withdrawal of funding for PiS by the PKW affect the right wing? Will a weakening party be able to maintain unity, vitality, and social support? So far, events suggest two things. Firstly, Kaczyński has a great ability to maintain dominance on the right. Secondly, if PiS regains power, we will face analogous problems, but in an intensified form – PiS will want to withdraw funding from Civic Coalition, without seeking a real justification. The medal should go to the person who comes up with a way to get off this carousel, which is not a carousel of laughter."
https://kulturaliberalna.pl/2024/09/02/sawczuk-decyzja-pkw-pis-straci-miliony/
-- IN THIS SITUATION, LAW AND JUSTICE IS BECOMING SOMETHING GREATER THAN A POLITICAL PARTY - MICHAŁ KARNOWSKI: "In this situation, Law and Justice is becoming something greater than a political party. It is currently the only large, organized force of Polish patriots, the only structure offering the possibility of restoring Poland to developmental and independent tracks in the future, the only real alternative when the consequences of bad governance become obvious and palpable to most Poles, the only force capable of defending the persecuted today. The Church, intimidated and partially co-opted by the authorities, unfortunately, is currently shying away from this task. Therefore, we must look at President Jarosław Kaczyński's formation as our ancestors looked at Mikołajczyk's PSL in the post-war period, Cardinal Wyszyński's Church during the Gomułka era, KOR and WZZ in Gierek's times, 'Solidarity' in the 1980s. These were the only possible but crucial forms of organization for Polish patriots for their survival at the time. This is the role that Law and Justice plays today – it is a movement to defend Poland and Poles, it is national self-defense."
https://wpolityce.pl/polityka/704241-co-teraz-robic-piec-najwazniejszych-wnioskow
-- AN OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE A STEP TOWARDS FULFILLING AT LEAST PARTIALLY THE RULING OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE CASE OF WAŁĘSA V. POLAND HAS BEEN WASTED. THIS RULING QUESTIONED, AMONG OTHER THINGS, THE POSITION OF NEO-JUDGES IN THE SUPREME COURT. AND THE PRIME MINISTER'S DECISION LEGITIMIZED THEM - PROF. EWA ŁĘTOWSKA IN AN INTERVIEW WITH KONRAD SADURSKI IN NEWSWEEK: "The zeal and efforts of many people and centers striving to restore the rule of law have been disregarded. Worse, an opportunity to take a step towards fulfilling at least partially the ruling of the European Court of Human Rights in the case of Wałęsa v. Poland has been wasted. This ruling questioned, among other things, the position of neo-judges in the Supreme Court. And the prime minister's decision legitimized them. And how can we demand now? Try? How can we work on restoring the rule of law step by step? Shouting, threatening with the prosecutor's office and 'getting them in their socks,' publicizing personnel changes in courts and the prosecution – restoring the rule of law cannot be reduced only to such actions."
-- I HAVE THE IMPRESSION THAT THE STIRRING UP OF THESE EXPECTATIONS FOR ACCOUNTABILITY HAS BECOME AN ELEMENT OF CONSCIOUS PROPAGANDA FOR US – AS INFOTAINMENT. HERE LIES A HUGE TRAP - PROF. ŁĘTOWSKA CONTINUES IN NEWSWEEK: "This danger constantly looms over us: that people will get tired and disgusted with the lack of agency and waiting for the fulfillment of political promises. Moreover, I have the impression that stirring up these expectations for accountability has become an element of conscious propaganda for us – as infotainment. Herein lies a huge trap for those in power who use such a propaganda strategy."
-- THE CONSTITUTIONAL TRIBUNAL PRACTICALLY DOESN'T EXIST. IT HAS LOST ITS AUTHORITY. SIMILARLY, TWO CHAMBERS OF THE SUPREME COURT - PROF. ŁĘTOWSKA CONTINUES WITH SADURSKI: "Well, the Constitutional Tribunal practically doesn't exist. It has lost its authority. Similarly, two chambers of the Supreme Court. Their degradation took a long time; and for an equally long time, step by step, through a series of rulings, their legitimacy and composition have been questioned in the ECJ and ECHR. But the conclusion of this process must be crowned by the formation and stabilization of internal practice within the Supreme Court and other state bodies. Currently, it is unstable. I will again only recall the recent confusion with the Prime Minister's countersignature, which delays this moment."
-- THE MINISTER HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE SUPREME COURT. MORE POSSIBILITIES LIE IN THE INTERNAL ACTIONS OF THIS COURT - PROF. ŁĘTOWSKA CONTINUES IN NEWSWEEK: "The minister has nothing to do with the Supreme Court. More possibilities lie in the internal actions of this court; we must wait and see what its judges will do, they must sort it out themselves. But the prime minister should at least not hinder them, which is precisely what he has done."
-- ONE MUST MAINTAIN OBJECTIVITY IN JUDGMENT TOWARDS SOMEONE YOU DISLIKE - PROF. ŁĘTOWSKA FURTHER STATES: "Believe me, using the law, enacting it, judging – these are truly very difficult things. One must maintain objectivity in judgment towards someone you dislike. And who likes the color gray? We prefer more distinct colors."
https://www.newsweek.pl/biznes/letowska-pociag-przywracania-praworzadnosci-jest-na-wlasciwych-szynach-ale-ma/ktl5mk1
-- BIRTHDAYS: Ryszard Terlecki, Bishop Krzysztof Zadarko, Ewa Kołodziej.
live
3 hours
16 min
Grabiec: Sometimes Vetoes Indicate the President Lacks Awareness of Government and Parliamentary Work
20 min
Grabiec: The President is a Bit in Campaign Rigor
48 min
„I Would Prefer the President Not to Authorize These Kinds of Undertakings.” — Tusk on Nawrocki's Participation in a Fans' Pilgrimage
51 min
Czarzasty: Today I will send the budget for the President's signature
2 hours
„The Government Was Completely Inactive.” — Andruszkiewicz on Blocking the EU-Mercosur Agreement
3 hours
„This Isn't a Malicious Act.” — Andruszkiewicz on the President's Veto Announcement on the Day of the Nawrocki-Tusk Meeting
3 hours
Andruszkiewicz: If a bill is in progress, it would be good for the government to seek the President's Office's comments and implement them
3 hours
Andruszkiewicz: The Prime Minister Seems to Have Had a New Year's Reflection
4 hours
„This Formation Should Remain on the Margins.” — Kaczyński Asked About Braun
state of play
STATE OF PLAY: Flieger: PiS Opponents Have Normalized 'Polexit' for Poles, Perhaps Even Pinned It on PiS; Szubartowicz: Can Governance in Poland Be Maintained Through Hegemony and Autocracy?
state of play
today
POLITICAL STATE OF PLAY: Kaczyński Distances Himself from Braun 'Even at the Cost of Stalemate,' Gądek: Kaczyński 'Spoke to Morawiecki' about a Multi-Nurtured Party, Stankiewicz: Pełczyńska Distributes Positions
state of play
yesterday
STATE OF PLAY: Watoła: Women Fear Giving Birth in Emergency Rooms, Ministry Ignores Them; Kalukin: Initial Sober Diagnoses of the Right Gradually Become Excessively Radicalized
state of play
01/07/2026
STATE OF PLAY: Cichocki: Why should we side with Russian or Chinese imperialism in Venezuela? Beylin: If we think the far-right has hit a wall, we are mistaken.
state of play
01/05/2026
STATE OF PLAY: Left-wing politician at Szpala: Kaczyński struggles with factions, Tusk gains backing from Czarzasty allowing him to challenge PiS and the President, Chwedoruk: PiS stagnation will progress
state of play
01/03/2026
STATE OF PLAY: Flis: These 8% of voters who currently choose Razem, PSL, or Poland 2050 will decide. GW: Tusk stopped the Left's project, Wójcik in Krytyka: Poland's further turn to the right
state of play
01/02/2026